← Back to Blog
Publications

Exploring the Lower Part of Discrete Polymer Model Energy Landscapes

This paper develops an efficient flooding-style algorithm for exploring the low-energy part of discrete polymer landscapes, making barrier-tree analysis feasible without exhaustive enumeration.

This paper continues the early energy-landscape line of work, but shifts the emphasis from formal representation to practical exploration. Once one accepts that barrier trees are a useful way to summarize a landscape, the next problem is obvious: how do we obtain the relevant low-energy portion of the landscape in the first place, especially when exhaustive enumeration is too expensive?

That is the question addressed here, and the paper proposes a generic algorithm for "flooding" the lower part of a discrete energy landscape starting from optimal and near-optimal conformations. Instead of trying to enumerate the full state space, the method selectively expands the part of the landscape that is actually relevant for basin structure, barrier heights, and subsequent dynamics analysis. The examples in the paper use lattice proteins in two and three dimensions, but the underlying idea is more general.

The methodological point matters, because many landscape-analysis methods become impractical not because the mathematics is unclear, but because the raw search space grows too quickly. This paper tackles that bottleneck directly: starting from structures produced by constraint-based search, it incrementally explores states below a chosen energy threshold and uses that information to reconstruct the low-energy topology of the landscape. In effect, it provides a computational route from a discrete optimization problem to a barrier-tree style description without requiring full enumeration of all states.

The low-energy region is where most of the folding behaviour of interest is found: local minima, the kinetically relevant basins, and the barriers separating them. A reliable map of this part of the landscape is the input for coarse-grained dynamics, metastability analysis, and structure-space visualization. The paper connects landscape theory with an exploration algorithm that can be run in practice.

The algorithm is formulated independently of the lattice protein model, and the same approach was later used for RNA landscape exploration, where the situation is the same: the full structure space is enormous, the subset relevant for folding kinetics is small and structured. The paper is one step on the path from discrete polymer models to the RNA landscape methods that followed.

For readers looking back from today's perspective, the significance of this work is not that it solves all exploration problems once and for all. It does something more realistic and more durable: it shows how to target the informative part of a large landscape efficiently enough that subsequent topology and dynamics analysis become possible. That remains one of the central engineering challenges in landscape analysis, regardless of whether the underlying system is a lattice polymer, an RNA secondary structure ensemble, or some other discrete configuration space.

Abstract of the paper

We present a generic, problem-independent algorithm for exploration of the low-energy portion of the energy landscape of discrete systems and apply it to the energy landscape of lattice proteins. Starting from a set of optimal and near-optimal conformations derived from a constraint-based search technique, we are able to selectively investigate the lower part of lattice protein energy landscapes in two and three dimensions. This novel approach allows, in contrast to exhaustive enumeration, for an efficient calculation of optimal and near-optimal structures below a given energy threshold and is only limited by the available amount of memory. A straightforward application of the algorithm is the calculation of barrier trees (representing the energy landscape), which then allows dynamics studies based on landscape theory.

Citation

Exploring the Lower Part of Discrete Polymer Model Energy Landscapes
Michael T. Wolfinger, Sebastian Will, Ivo L. Hofacker, Rolf Backofen, Peter F. Stadler
Europhys. Lett. 74(4): 726–32 (2006) | doi:10.1209/epl/i2005-10577-0 | Preprint PDF

See Also

Memory Efficient RNA Energy Landscape Exploration
Martin Mann, Marcel Kucharík, Christoph Flamm, Michael T. Wolfinger
Bioinformatics 30: 2584–91 (2014) | doi:10.1093/bioinformatics/btu337 | PDF

BarMap: RNA Folding on Dynamic Energy Landscapes
Ivo L. Hofacker, Christoph Flamm, Michael Heine, Michael T. Wolfinger, Gerik Scheuermann, Peter F. Stadler
RNA 16:1308–16 (2010) | doi:10.1261/rna.2093310 | PDF

Efficient Computation of RNA Folding Dynamics
Michael T. Wolfinger, W. Andreas Svrcek-Seiler, Christoph Flamm, Ivo L. Hofacker, Peter F. Stadler
J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 37(17): 4731–41 (2004) | doi:10.1088/0305-4470/37/17/005 | PDF

Barrier Trees of Degenerate Landscapes
Christoph Flamm, Ivo L. Hofacker, Peter F. Stadler, Michael T. Wolfinger
Z. Phys. Chem. 216: 155–73 (2002) | doi:10.1524/zpch.2002.216.2.155 | Preprint PDF